Which name brands really make store-brand products? We start with Costco's Kirkland Signature line, grade every claim by the strength of its paper trail, and compare prices with the name brand.
Every product added, every grade changed and every correction, by date.
The only support for the krill oil maker is a Costco catalog field we cannot see, the same kind of claim we leave unconfirmed elsewhere.
Ten claims were rechecked against registers, label approvals, safety sheets and maker statements, and twelve products people search for were added. Each grade follows the record we could open.
Filled gaps found by comparing six rival sites. Each new maker is graded on the record we could open; rival claims alone are marked reported, not confirmed.
We added name-brand unit-price comparisons for medicines, food, drinks, spirits and household goods, plus more Kirkland wines beside the producer's own bottle. New pages list every maker and the myths that don't hold up. Each product page now shows the type of evidence behind its grade.
We checked about 200 more Kirkland Signature products against labels, recalls, drug label records and other records. Products where we found no maker are listed too, so you can still compare prices. Every product now has its own page.
We checked claims that circulate in forums and blogs, bringing the list to 68, and traced Kirkland wines to their producers with a price comparison against the producer's own bottle.
The tracker started with 45 Kirkland Signature claims, each graded by the best public record we could link: labels, recall notices, federal label approvals and statements on the record.