Data checked 2026-11-18

Store Brand Tracker

Which name brands really make store-brand products? We start with Costco's Kirkland Signature line, grade every claim by the strength of its paper trail, and compare prices with the name brand.

← Dairy & eggs

No photo yet. A clear photo of the label also helps confirm the maker.

Kirkland Signature Sweet Cream Butter, Salted and Unsalted, 4 x 1 lb

ConfirmedDairy & eggsUnclear if current

What the record shows

Evidence type: Official record

FDA recall notice. Continental Dairy Facilities Southwest was the recalling firm for about 79,000 lb of Kirkland salted and unsalted butter in October 2024 (FDA recalls F-0121-2025 and F-0122-2025). Butter for other regions may come from other plants, which the dairy plant code on the wrapper shows.

Sources

  1. FDA Enforcement Report, butter recall event 95556 (Oct 2024)
  2. Penn State Food Safety blog, butter recall summary with FDA recall numbers (Nov 2024)
  3. Fox Business, Costco butter recall report (Nov 2024)
  4. Chowhound, where Kirkland butter comes from (Nov 2026)

Price vs the name brand

Kirkland Signature$0.14/oz$8.99 for 4 lb (64 oz), seen Nov 2026
Land O Lakes Salted Butter Sticks, 1 lb (Walmart)$0.36/oz$5.78 for 16 oz, seen Nov 2026
Difference61% lessKirkland per oz

Costco prices vary by region and change often. Prices are what the linked pages showed on the date given. A lower price doesn't mean the products are the same.

Last checked 2026-11-18. Have a label photo or a record that changes this? Send a correction.