Data checked 2026-11-18

Store Brand Tracker

Which name brands really make store-brand products? We start with Costco's Kirkland Signature line, grade every claim by the strength of its paper trail, and compare prices with the name brand.

← Pantry & snacks

No photo yet. A clear photo of the label also helps confirm the maker.

Kirkland Signature Organic Creamy Peanut Butter, 28 oz

ConfirmedPantry & snacksPast supplier

What the record shows

Evidence type: Official record

FDA recall (enforcement report F-0434-2013). The FDA enforcement report for Sunland's 2012 Salmonella recall lists Kirkland organic creamy peanut butter, 28 oz, so Sunland made it at that time. We found nothing naming today's maker. The Hampton Farms claim has no traceable source.

Sources

  1. FDA enforcement report F-0434-2013, Sunland recall (Oct 2012)

Price vs the name brand

Kirkland Signature$0.18/oz$9.99 for 2 x 28 oz (56 oz), seen Nov 2026
Smucker's Organic Creamy Peanut Butter, 16 oz$0.36/oz$5.73 for 16 oz, seen Nov 2026
Difference50% lessKirkland per oz

Costco prices vary by region and change often. Prices are what the linked pages showed on the date given. A lower price doesn't mean the products are the same.

Last checked 2026-11-18. Have a label photo or a record that changes this? Send a correction.